Recipes With Allspice
Got allspice on hand? Here are 37 recipes you can make with it, ranked by how few extra ingredients they need — the simplest matches come first.
Pairs well with
Onion Cinnamon Garlic Virgin Olive Oil Thyme Eggs Flour Coconut Milk
Storing & using Allspice
Fresh herbs keep longest wrapped loosely and refrigerated; dried herbs and spices last longest in a cool, dark cupboard, away from the stove. Out of Allspice? cinnamon + nutmeg + cloves is a common swap (equal mix). Single spice, not a blend, despite the name.
Allspice recipe FAQs
What can I make with just allspice?
Start with the simplest recipes above — most lean on onion or a few everyday staples alongside it.
What goes well with allspice?
Onion, Cinnamon, Garlic, Virgin Olive Oil, Thyme are the most common pairings in our recipes.
How do I find recipes for allspice plus what else I have?
Use Cook with what you have (/pantry/) — add allspice plus anything else in your kitchen, and recipes rank by how many you already own.